I visited Frantz today. We tried to visit him last week and got turned away. Apparently we were a few minutes too late to be let in, though after looking at posted visiting hours again, we couldn't figure out why. It was interesting. Especially since the girl in front of us in line was allowed to visit. She argued with the corrections officer and they let her in. We didn't argue. I don't know if it would have helped. When we got to the front of the line, the woman took one look at us and asked if we were social workers or lawyers. It turned out to be a thought-provoking question for me (not because I don't know that I am NOT either of those things). Why would she think by just looking at us that we weren't regular visitors? It caused me to think a lot about social and economic classes and education. And how those things contribute to how you dress and talk and even carry yourself. Anyway, she didn't let us in.
So, today I got to thinking about a whole lot of things. Some were caused by the fascinating conversation we had with Frantz. Some by just watching other inmates and their visitors in the visiting room, and some by the entire process of getting there and going through security. Here are just a few of the things on my mind:
We completely take our freedom for granted. The prison is about an hour's drive from Cambridge, and my friend and I are constantly trying out new routes to get there. We decided to skip our normal exit on the freeway and as we were worrying about the possiblity of getting lost, it hit me how ironic it was that we have the choice to just turn another way on the freeway, or to get lost or skip town or whatever, and Frantz has had that completely taken away and has never known it as an adult. Merely in the process of going to see him, we were taking for granted things that he doesn't enjoy.
We discussed the criminal justice system with him today: sentences, parole boards, the ages of offenders. I ended up asking him how he thought we should structure our justice system. He is so insightful. I wonder why people in his situation aren't consulted at least a little when policy is being formulated. He talked about how it all depends upon what your goal and your philosophy is. Are you striving for punishment or rehabilitation? Or both? Is the goal "an eye for an eye" or something else? He felt that many people DID need to be punished. He discussed victim-perpetrator reconciliation programs. He also talked about the utter waste it is to try a teenager as an adult and then to put them away for life without parole. As he was saying this, I was looking at a kid who was visiting with what looked like his parents, and he looked about 16.
What kind of life do you have trying to maintain a relationship or raise a family with your spouse in prison? Or when you are the one in prison?
Forgiveness and healing are important.
Hearing Frantz talk about "vicim's families" added a whole new dimension to my thoughts about incarceration and the justice system. Nothing I can clearly articulate.
I feel almost more strongly about rape than I do about murder.
Just a few of the many things my day has caused me to think about.
6 comments:
"we have the choice to just turn another way on the freeway, or to get lost or skip town or whatever, and Frantz has had that completely taken away"
Not to sound heartless or anything, but I think it's an important point that (assuming the justice system was correct in incarcerating someone) freedoms are not taken away - they are given up by the choices we make.
I agree, and yet it's complicated. I think that's the point of my entry. And, we do take those things for granted when we have them. That's the point of that paragraph.
The whole conversation is further complicated when we consider that the public spends several thousand dollars each month for each prisoner in the system. We pay more to keep a man in prison per month than we do to educate a child, treat a client with substance abuse or mental illness issues, or pay out to most upstanding senior citizens on social security. Seems strange to me.
This is something I have no answer for, and Frantz has a few insightful things to say.
Have you seen The Shawshank Redemption? It is fiction of course, and does not accurately depict prison life. But there is something that stands out from the movie.
Red says, "These walls are funny. First you hate them, then you get used to them, and you rely on them. They send you here for life and that is exactly what they take."
The prison system neither punishes nor rehabilitates the incarcerated. It institutionalizes them.
These institutionalized people get released and come right back because they are woefully prepared for the outside world. That is what the prison system does to people, and I thought the movie painfully illustrated it.
Well said, David.
Tania, would you mind filling me in on who Frantz is? I'd like to compare experiences ... I recently saw that yet another friend of mine has gone to jail.
(Making three in total, at intervals of just over four years; you might want to think twice about being my friend in late 2010.)
You all bring up really good points which definitely add to the discussion. It's a tough situation, and I have no idea what the answer is. I just am becoming more and more aware how complicated it is.
@David: I have not seen that movie, but it came up in conversation between my friend and Frantz yesterday.
@Nathan: http://mydesertedisland.blogspot.com/2005/11/prison-education-project.html
That should explain who Frantz is.
Post a Comment