In my children's literature course, we've been reading a fantasy trilogy I've never read before. It is extremely well written and engaging; I haven't been able to put it down. In fact, we only needed to read one of the three books for this week, and I ended up reading all three (yes, I'm a big enough nerd that I am now 800 pages ahead). Yet, the basic theological premise of these books,which wasn't fully clear until the end, deeply distrubed me, and made me wonder if these were books I'd want my children reading. It's an interesting thing to think about, and in our class discussions I've thought much about the idea of censorship. I firmly believe that there are some very clear things that should be censored and that I would never allow in my home, my life, or in my children's lives (an obvious example would be anything at all sexually explicit). Yet, where do we draw the censorship line when it comes to ideas?
Earlier this semester we read the Chronicles of Narnia, and I was amazed at the major problems that some of my classmates had with these books. I found that I was quick to defend them, mostly because of my positive experience with this series as a child and my admiration for Lewis' more serious works as an adult. Yet, as I read them this time around, I had to concede to many of their points. For example, the Chronicles are extremely violent. I never noticed the violence before, probably because I find war scenes in books boring and have always skimmed over them. Some of my classmates who are not Christian described being upset when, as adults, they discovered how very "Christian" were the books they had read as children. Agreeing with much with Lewis' theology, I obviously didn't have this problem. Yet, it made me wonder what I would think if it were an analogy for the religious story of some other tradition and not my own. As we discussed Lewis' books, I honestly believed I wouldn't mind. My response was simply that if you didn't agree with the ideas put forth in the books, read them alongside your child and discuss the ideas in them. Children know the difference between real and make-believe, and aren't going to take as truth all that they read. Plus, I really can't think of an example of any book of fiction that formed my religious understanding. I hardly remember most of what I read as a child, and I'm sure that a lot of symbolism went over my head. I was merely reading what I saw as "a good story." However, I wonder how much ideas influence us subconciously.
Anyway, reading this trilogy has caused me to think some more about the topic. It is not a story belonging to another faith, instead it has fairly blatant anti-Christian undertones. Now, I don't want my children to be naive and to struggle unnecessarily when they are eventually exposed to worldly ideas that differ from mine. I want them to learn to think through even difficult things, to pray, and to find truth for themselves with the help of the Spirit. I want to foster the kinds of discussions in my home that will help them think for themselves, while assuring them that there are answers to questions. Yet, I do want to shelter them a little. They are going to be bringing enough difficult stuff in from the world, without me giving it to them in my home, which I want to be a place of safety, faith, and love. So, where do I draw the line? Obviously there are books and discussions that are age-appropriate.
Just some things I've been thinking about . . .
3 comments:
Good post!
I think the key is to encourage people (not just children) to think for themselves and take ownership of what they believe.
Now I am curious as to what this triology is about. You don't want to tell us the name of it? Don't make me lose sleep over this :).
Jeje, I've been thinking along similar lines recently, as I've pondered one of my favorite book and wondered how I would feel if a child of mine were reading it. I think that the key for me would be to read along with them and discuss it, just as you said.
I think that it would be a wonderful opportunity to share something I love (reading and learning about new things) with my child-- just as my parents have shared it with me. :)
@ David: It's Philip Pullman's "His Dark Materials" trilogy: The Golden Compass, The Subtle Knife, and The Amber Spyglass.
Post a Comment