Tuesday, August 01, 2006

Falling in Love

Arranged marriages are still relatively common in Fiji. When I was there, I would often get asked if I wanted a "love marriage" or a "fixed marriage." I would respond that my culture didn't really have arranged marriages and therefore I would marry for love. Then I would change the subject while breaking the hearts of all of the mothers who wanted to set me up with their sons. I must admit that when I first got there, I was horrified at the idea that people could marry someone that someone else chose for them. It seemed to me like it would be the blind date that just never ended. As I spent more and more time there, however, I started to watch the marriages around me, and I realized that there were positives to arranged marriages (and no, I'm not talking about the benefits of avoiding the dating scene). Some (not all) of the people I knew that were in an arranged marriage had entered marriage without unrealistic expectations. They didn't think that love was what had been painted for them in hollywood movies. They knew marriage would be hard, and so when difficult times came, they were committed and stuck it out, and most had grown to love their spouse and were happy. It reminds me of the scene in Fiddler on the Roof where Tevye asks Golda, his wife of 25 years, if she loves him. At first she thinks it's a ridiculous question after everything they've been through together. However, as they sing a beautiful song about their life together (how I love musicals!), they realize that they do love each other. It's sweet. Real love involves commitment and helping each other through things.

I did see bad things in arranged marriages, however. I don't know how many families I saw where husband and wife had nothing in common and didn't talk, or where there was infidelity. So, I saw pros and cons in both "love" and "fixed" marriages.

All that being said, I am still a hopeless romantic in my own expectations. Now don't get me wrong. I recognize that regardless of how madly in love with someone I may be there will come a day when the honeymoon is over and things are hard. Real love is all about commitment when it is hard. However, I still think that I shouldn't have to settle for less than being head over heels in love with someone who is head over heels in love with me.

I was talking with a friend last night about this. This friend is trying to decide whether or not to get married. He loves his girlfriend, and she is his best friend, but he is not sure he is in love with her, and isn't sure if he wants to marry her. She is madly in love with him, and the last thing he wants to do is hurt her, or give up a good thing. And he does love her. Yet, he doesn't feel the same intensity of feelings for her that he has felt in the past. Part of him feels like he should just get married and through that commitment he will be happy. And yet there is another part of him that feels as though he would be settling. Does he have unrealisitic expectations?

Now, I can completely see both sides of the issue. Yet my feeling is still that I wouldn't want to marry someone if they weren't completely excited about marrying me. Shouldn't you WANT to get married? Shouldn't it be the easiest decision you'll ever make?

I have a lot more I could say about this, but this post is already way too long. Perhaps I'll write a part 2. But, what do you all think? Normally I'm pretty practical. Am I too much of a romantic when it comes to my thoughts on this?

5 comments:

B said...

I will try to refrain from writing a response that could actually be an entire blog. Oh the thoughts and feeling that I have concerning this very matter. The extremely short answer to this is that I think that marriage is tough enough and I will only enter into it with someone that I can't imagine ever not being at their side once I have found them and I want them to feel the exact same way. Best friends and madly in love. I don't think for one second that I am asking for too much because my parents have it, my siblings have it and most of my friends have it. It is possible if you are willing to wait for it.

Kate said...

I completely agree with JRA-- Unless I can not see myself without that person by my side for the rest of my life, I'm not so sure I'd want to dive into it. I have learned a lot from my parents, enough to know that it can't all rest on that feeling of being in love at the first. It takes work, work that I only want to put in with the right person for me.

Sarah said...

I have to say, not ever haveing to make such a decision, I don't have a clue what it would be like. There are some things to consider. There are questions that need to be asked. Why would he feel like he's settling? Is it because he feels there might be someone better suited for him? etc. I do think one should never feel like they are settling and I think it is never easy to make huge decisions no matter what it involves, so I think doubt is going to be a part of it, but in the end you should feel it is 100% right for both people. Also I think it is important for both people involved to be completly honest about what they think. No one should ever get married because they think it is what they or other people think they should do because they have been together for a long time. Sorry.... I'l stop now.

American Girl said...

Can I just say ditto to the above? I also think I would rather not marry someone who isn't totally in love with me. Sure it would hurt at first, but there might definitely be something better waiting.

Nathan said...

Why do we so entangle 'settling on' with 'settling for', and 'being in love' with loving?

Put it this way: There was a girl once who I wanted to date, who wanted to date me, and who I could imagine going through my whole life with. We were great friends, and she would have been a great wife and mother. But I didn't feel 'madly in love' and I didn't pursue it.

This girl has now acquired three things: From another man, a new surname and the title Mrs. -- and from me, the title Only Girl I Ever Think Of With Regret. We both had the capacity and the will to love, and I let it slide for thinking too much about being in love.

(For my part, around the time she was getting married, I did fall madly in love with a girl whose friendship is pretty much unparalleled in my life ... and who does not reciprocate my mad in-love-ness. In context of my previous experience, this naturally drives me up a wall.)