Thursday, April 06, 2006

Playing the "What If. . ." Game

I led the discussion in my biomedical ethics class yesterday. The topic was "care in an aging society" and centered around issues related to caring for patients with dementia. One huge aspect of the discussion was the role of Advance Care Directives or living wills, including their efficacy and shortcomings. Ethicists recommend that everyone make a living will if for no other reason than to spark important discussions within families on end of life preferences so that when people are put in difficult situations as proxy decision makers, they will have some idea of what their loved one would have liked, even if it is a fuzzy idea, or at least an idea of who their loved one would have wanted to make these kinds of decisions on their behalf.

How do you begin a conversation like that? I think I would be comfortable once a discussion was begun, but explaining why I feel the need, at age 24, to discuss my medical preferences should I end up unable to make those decisions for myself, would be awkward. And yet, I'm developing opinions on things - particularly after working in a hospital last year. Plus, I think it would be valuable to know my parents' opinions, and to discuss those with my siblings. Incapacitation and death are uncomfortable subjects. I suppose we're all much more content not having these kinds of conversations, valuable as they may be, because we do not want to imagine losing the people that we love (mentally or physically). Yet, such conversations may bring some measure of comfort to hypothetical future situations.

3 comments:

will said...

great post. the first thing that came to mind as i read-which i'm sure came to most-was the schiavo case. being in that situation without a way to express any desire or emotion would be worse to me than prison. i would want the plug to be pulled and fast, which is quite an eye opener because i don't believe my family would take that step either. perhaps that'll be the topic for discussion at dinner this weekend. thanks isla

C.J. said...

I agree that these kinds of conversations need to be held, awkward or not. I think it is so strange that we have such difficulty talking about death in our culture. In general we do not handle death very well, whether we are talking about wills before death or the grieving process after. I know that sounds weird, but there are other cultures where the subject is not so taboo. I think death is harder on all of us because we don't talk about it much before it happens and after it happens we aren't allowed to truly grieve. I recently discovered that my place of work gives 3 hours funeral leave for those who are not immediate family members!

Heidi said...

I've actually had this discussion a few times with my parents and my husband (so I'm not in the same situation as Terry Schiavo if that ever happens to me). I think, as uncomfortable as it may be to talk about, it would be even worse not to have a say in what happens to you. Fortunately, all my family feels about it the same way I do.