A couple of weeks ago I was at a friend's house for dinner. Also at dinner was a guy whose name I've heard a lot, but have no recollection of ever meeting. All of my Boston friends seem to hang out with this boy, yet I'd never met him. So, I finally met him. I didn't think much of it. He seemed like a nice guy who contributed to the conversation at dinner. Fairly attractive. Obviously very bright. The missionaries were in attendance and so conversation centered mostly around church-type things.
After dinner was over and people were scattering, he turned to me and said some stuff that really bothered me. It bothered me so much that I'm still thinking about it. He said something to the effect of , "I've only known you for 10 minutes or so, and I could be totally wrong, but I get the impression that you don't trust men." I didn't know how to respond to that. While I was gasping for air (I had done nothing to provoke this conversation), he said, "Again, I could be wrong, but you just seem kind of skeptical and maybe a little cynical." While trying to figure out what we had discussed at dinner that could have brought on such impressions, I replied, "I try not to be." "Do you have to try really hard?" was his response.
I don't remember how the conversation ended. But I couldn't stop thinking about it. First of all, do I come across that way? Secondly, what had I done to give him such an impression? And why would he feel the need to tell me these things out of nowhere when he didn't know me at all? It was all very strange. To make things worse, after that evening, I ran into him everywhere. I mean, everywhere. And he was really nice to me every time I met him. I had gone 5 months hearing his name and not meeting him, and then I bump into him every time I turn around, all the while thinking about this conversation.
Finally, it bugged me so much that I asked him about it at a party. He's a law student and treated my approaching him and our subsequent conversation as an exercise in rhetoric. Everything I said in trying to ask him about this or to clear the air between us was met with a hostile question or responses such as "If it weren't true, you wouldn't be thinking about it," and "obviously you care about my opinion of you if its bothering you this much." I was on the defensive, and I suppose that may have come out in my responses to him.
I don't like this at all. Not at all. The funny thing is that even though I've found him annoying and exasperating on these two occasions, I've observed sides of him that lead me to believe we could be good friends under different circumstances. It just doesn't make sense to me. And I'm still wondering about his comments.
5 comments:
I have come across people like him. Obviously I don't know the guy, so I can only rely on your account. But there's a lot of people like that who claim to be so perceptive, yet they really aren't. If he were that perceptive, than he should have been thoughtful enough to have kept it to himself. It's none of his business.
It takes years to get to know people, and even trained psychologists need to sit with you one on one for at least 10 sessions to get a good handle on you. And even so, I don't think most psychologists get it right even after 10 sessions later.
People who make such claims tend to be quite manipulative and even deceptive, which may explain his popularity. He's already manipulated you into thinking about it, for which he appears to be patting himself on the back. What a puke inducer that is.
See how cynical I am? :-)
Well, I certainly can't say much about this gentleman, except that the abrupt comment and the way in which it was expressed are both very weird! Normal people don't make those kinds of statements to people they just met. But, I suppose you could give him the benefit of the doubt that he is just a very expressive person. In my experience with you I have not noticed a particular distrust for men, nor have I felt you give that impression. Maybe you were acting guarded because of your attraction for him, and he sensed that. Just because you are thinking about it doesn't mean it's true, but it may well mean that you do care about his opinion. However, anyone who makes a statement like that but fails to explain their reasons, instead turning it back on you, probably has no reasons. He himself said that he could be wrong. Next time it comes up I would recommend saying as much.
David: I never would have pegged you as cynical. Hmm . . .
ST: You're right, I should give him the benefit of the doubt. And, I never said I was attracted to him.
You're right. You never said it...but did you feel it?? Remember you said he was "fairly attractive. Obviously very bright." You know I'm just giving you a hard time, right?! :)
Ah I can hear the wedding bells all the way from here in California ... :-).
Well, you already gave him the benefit of the doubt by seeking elaboration, but he dodged.
Post a Comment