Thursday, October 20, 2005

A Political & Religious Question

I get questioned often about my view on same-sex marriage. You all, obviously, know my view. I've explained it different ways, but still feel that there must be a better way. How would you discuss such a question? Particularly if the person asking sincerely wants to understand you? Or if the inquirer does not believe in God?

4 comments:

C.J. said...

This is a tuff one for sure. First of all, I think it is wise to point out that you believe people have the right to live any kind of lifestyle they are inclined to choose, provided it is not a direct or indirect danger to those around them. However, when peoples lifestyle choices begin to affect others and even society, there is a need for social and legal limits. This particular situation fits this category. Here are a few things to think about.

-Marriage between man and woman is ordained of God to achieve His work and glory. (Doesn't go over well with atheists/agnostics or liberally minded folks, yet it is the fundamental principle behind your argument, there is no sidestepping this crucial point. From our doctrinal perspective the whole purpose of life is to become like God. This requires eternal union between man and woman and creation of families. This can get sticky, but it can help people see why you believe the way you believe.)

-History teaches us much. Every culture in every era of time, even when they were not connected in any way has practiced, and practices marriage. Has homosexuality existed in every age and culture? Yes, undoubtedly, sometimes on a large scale and quite openly (Greeks, Romans, Asians). And yet, never has any culture promoted or permitted either socially or legally the equivalent of marriage to same-sex couples. A few obscure Indian tribes have been much more accepting of a homosexual lifestyle, and even they have not married same-sex couples. Should we be careful in altering a social institution that has been defined by ions of history and tradition? Isn't there something to be learned here?

-Gay marriage will ultimately lead to legal adoption by same-sex couples. Isn't that good you ask? Afterall, there are so many kids waiting for homes. Are gay people capable of being loving and effective parents? Absolutely, some probably better than the thugs who beat, molest, or neglect their children. However, the best and most ideal situation for children is in a loving home with a father and a mother. This has been shown in research time and time again. But, hold on, studies show that there is no difference between children raised in heterosexual homes and homosexual homes, and that there is no difference in future homosexual tendencies. Well, these studies are too few, not representative, short-term, and questionable. Furthermore, we have no idea what the long term effects on society as a whole might be. You can argue 'till the cows come home, but the fact of the matter is, men and women are different, and when there is not appropriate attachment and association with two parents, man and woman, there are challenges that arise. What about single parents, does that mean we should take away their kids? No, but no one can argue that there are many problems that arise from boys not having an appropriate male figure that teaches them about and affirms their manhood. It is interesting to note that research shows there is a difference when there is death of a parent and when there is divorce. Somehow, the positive regard of the live parent toward the deceased parent is a mitigating factor. The point is that policy should address the ideal, most beneficial situations for society. Obviously there will be exceptions. There is really no problem with homosexuals raising a child, so long as they are a man and a woman and are in an appropriate relationship.

-Marriage does not discriminate. Marriage is the union of a man and woman. That is the definition. Any man can marry any woman, whether they are black, white, homosexual, young, old, fat, thin, disabled, rich, or poor.

-Isn't opposition to same-sex marriage really just discrimination, as it was with bi-racial marriage in decades past? No, that was racism. The issue now is about changing what marriage means.

-Are heterosexual marriages so insecure that they feel same-sex marriage is a threat to marriage? No, this is about the "institution" of marriage. Not individual marriages. In general we have seen that it is not effective to legislate morality (prohibition). We are not out to say a person cannot be homosexual, but there are limits that come with the choices they make.

-Hang on there now. Homosexuality is not a choice? How could you be so cold hearted as to deny someone the right to make a commitment to the person they love? This argument pulls at the heartstrings and appeals to the deeply held values of equality and human rights in America. I have empathy for those in this situation. I have every reason to believe that they really do love their partners, and they really do feel that they had no choice in their sexual feelings. Most often, they did not. But the fact is that we do not know where homosexuality comes from. It is certain that genetics, environment, personality, and experiences interplay to create same-sex attraction. Thousands of men and women all over the world feel such attractions, but also see that they are at odds with their values. It is a painful, excruciating, and enormously difficult experience, but they stand as witnesses that it is possible to control, deal with, and even change those attractions without acting out on them or joining the gay lifestyle. This may mean, but not always, that they remain abstinent and/or without a spouse their entrie life. Such an idea is appalling to much of the world. I mean, gosh, shouldn't we always just do what "feels right" and "feels good"? There is power in sacrifice and there is profound growth that occurs through tremendous challenges.

In short we believe that same-sex marriage is unwise, because it is contrary to God's plan, it is unhealthy for families in the long run, and it is potentially harmful to society as a whole. It is not that it is any more or less harmful than a lot of other things, but that doesn't mean we should embrace it. This may be difficult to share with someone, particularly someone who is homosexual - but I think it can be done with sensitivity.

Jeje said...

Thanks, Silent. Great suggestions for me.

C.J. said...

As if I haven't already said enough. I forgot one point. Generally polls show that the great majority of Americans are opposed to same-sex marriage (upwards of 70%). Yet, it appears this issue will be resolved in the courts. The "full faith and credit clause" of the constitution could potentially require every state to recognize marriages performed in other states (like Mass. which allows same-sex marriage), despite their own amendments and/or statutes to the contrary. In other words, 7 or 8 state judges could potentially be deciding this issue for the entire nation. Judicial activism at its best.

American Girl said...

I think Silent Thunder has said it best. I especially agree with his first statement that it is important to point out that every individual is entitled to live whatever lifestyle they choose. We all have agency.

I work at a very liberal high school where some of the teachers are homosexual and so are many of the students. I have had to basically state to some when asked that I don't agree with homosexuallity, but I believe that it is a person's right to be who they want to be. And as long as they treat me nicely then I will do the same in return. I have made some great friends that way.