However, his plan to give this speech is creating much controversy. Many parents feel that he will use this as an opportunity to promote his own agenda and policies and to indoctrinate our nation's children without their parents' permission or presence. Schools, including the one where I teach, have been receiving angry phone calls from parents who do not want their children to hear from our nation's president. There are even parents who are comparing our elected leader to Hitler.
I have several points I want to make about this mess, which I believe is being blown WAY out of proportion. First of all, I want to stress that President Obama has been elected by the people as the President of the United States. As much as people may disagree with his actions and policies, I believe that the office itself deserves respect. I personally did not vote for the man, nor do I agree with many of his ideas or actions and often criticize them. However, the fact remains that he is our president and as such deserves courtesy and respect, even as we disagree with and even fight against his policies. The beauty of our nation is that the people elect their officials for limited periods of time, and that when elections don't go the way that individuals want, we don't have rioting in the streets, civil unrest and murder. We don't even worry that such things might happen. We're more blessed than we think in this respect as this is not the case around the world. Our governmental structure works because we have respect for the way things are set up, and we respect the voice of the people. It is out of respect for the Constitution that we ought to respect the office of the Presidency even as we are unhappy with the temporary person who is filling that office. I felt this way when all of the "Bush-bashing" was going on, and I feel this way now.
My second point: if President Obama were trying to indoctrinate schoolchildren without parent's approval or presence, he would not broadcast the speech live on the Internet where anyone can view it, from anywhere. Parents can watch it if they like, and they don't even need to go to their child's school to see it. If they do decide to do so, I don't know of any school that would object to a parent's presence. If this still isn't enough, I don't know of any school that would force a child to watch a speech if a parent asked for their child to be involved in an alternate activity. Besides, the study materials sent out to schools regarding the speech focus on goal setting, and getting an education. He really doesn't seem to have an ulterior motive behind this speech.
My third point: are parents that afraid of their children hearing something that they disagree with, especially when they have full access to hear exactly what their children heard? It is a good opportunity for parents to discuss something with their children and to teach them how to evaluate information that they hear. Their children will hear all kinds of things during their lifetime, and learning to filter and process it is a valuable skill that parents should teach.
I realize that, at least here in Utah, this has become an even bigger deal due to a Farmington school showing a service video last week which was made by the Obama administration. The school did not preview the video first, and while the main point of the video was to encourage service, portions of it showed celebrities speaking in support of Obama's policies, including stem-cell research funding. The principal ending up sending apologies home to parents. This incident was bad timing in relation to the upcoming speech and has fueled the fire of paranoia regarding indoctrination.
As a result of all the controversy, our school will preview the video first, and then if it really is just an encouraging education speech and an opportunity to hear from the President of the United States, we'll show it on Wednesday. Probably a good idea.
However, I still thing the whole controversy is ridiculous.













